It is that time of year at Sugar Plum Bakery! It’s Pie Time!

Let us help your family celebrate the holidays with a freshly baked homemade pie. We make is possible to satisfy anyone’s pie craving with our delectable assortment of pie flavors!

Pre order your pies by Saturday, November 17 and Receive 10% off.
Keep in mind all orders must be prepaid!!

Pumpkin Pie

Our pumpkin pie is creamy and full of pumpkin flavor.  Sure to be a family favorite.
$15.95

Pecan Pie

Homemade filling loaded with pecans.  Sure to please everyone.
$19.95

Apple Pie

This pie is packed full of flavorful apple slices and is available with crumb topping or whole crust.
$17.95

Sugar Plum Berry Pie

A pie that is baked to perfection with blueberries, cranberries, and cherries.  So extraordinary we had to give it our name!  Your choice of lattice, crumb or whole crust.
$19.95

Cherry Pie

For all the cherry lovers.  Available in whole crust.
$15.95

Blueberry Pie

This pie is bursting with wild blueberries.  Available in lattice crust only.
$15.95

French Apple Pie

A whole crust pie with a dense filling of apples and raisins.  The top is covered with a light white icing that adds the perfect amount of sweetness.
$21.95

Colonial Apple Pie

This handmade pie is four pounds of red apples mixed with cinnamon sugar and wrapped in a flaky, tender crust for a unique rustic look.
$28.00

Lemon Meringue Pie

Tangy lemon filling topped with fluffy, handmade meringue.  A great dessert sure to please.
$16.95

Coconut Cream Pie

A wonderful blend of coconut and cream topped with homemade whipped cream and coated with toasted coconut.
$17.95

Chocolate Mousse Pie

A chocolate lovers dream!  Creamy chocolate mousse topped with whipped cream and garnished with chocolate shavings.
$19.95

Praline Pecan Pumpkin Pie

A delicious twist on a holiday tradition.  This is our homemade pumpkin pie filling baked with a praline pecan topping.
$18.95

Caramel Apple Walnut Pie

Fresh apple pie with rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious.  Just one bite and you’ll see why this apple pie is so special.
$17.95

Snowflake Rolls

Old fashioned potato rolls made fresh
$4.80 a dozen

Dinner Rolls

Made from scratch yeast rolls!
$4.80 a dozen

Pumpkin Spice Cake

A torte cake made with our famous homemade pumpkin pound cake and layers of maple pecan cream cheese icing. The cake is finished with crushed pecans and maple icing drizzle.

6 inch  $28.00
8 inch $35.00